Since 1966, Sammy’s Fish Box has proudly continued the great tradition of sourcing and serving only the very best and freshest seafood to our dedicated customers. Every single dish is crafted with deep passion, prepared to absolute perfection, and served in the legendary, massive portions we have been famous for since day one. We believe that a great meal isn’t just about the food on the plate, but about honoring the loyalty of the generations of guests who step through our doors.
Located in the heart of City Island, we treat every dining experience as a grand celebration of community, flavor, and family. From our iconic, over-the-top seafood platters to our welcoming, high-energy atmosphere, we strive to ensure that every visit turns into an unforgettable feast. We remain fully committed to maintaining the high standards that have made us a landmark institution, bringing families and friends together over exceptional food for decades to come.
Our delicious version topped with
creamed spinach & mozzarella cheese
Golden brown, sweet and crisp
Crispy shrimp tossed in our creamy spicy sauce
a spicy flavored seafood dish pan-seared shrimp in a blend of garlic and Habanero peppers
Shrimp, Fillet of Fish, Scallops & Calamari
